Transsexed, Transgendered and Crossdresser Brains are the Same

Posted: September 2, 2009 in Troll Wars

Dolores Park In a comment Joanne writes:

I believe in substantive evidence and forensics. Thats why I believe this:
http://joanneproctor-hbs.blogspot.com/2009/08/organization-activation-brain-biology.html
Now, instead of using a classical transsexed / intersexed yardstick to understand your own issues, why don’t you give some consideration to the way science and biology works?

At least we have a common base of empirical evidence to cite. I recommend Diamond’s 2009 survey for an overview of the state of the research.
in her blog post Joanne writes:

Gender identity – does everybody really have one? Organization-activation theory actually allows for the possibility of some individuals, namely those whose organization and activation is very weak, to acquire a miss-targeted gender role and expression – or even to experience ambivalence in their sense of feeling male or female.

Joanne seems to be hypothesizing that Gender identity is a result of Organization-activation in the womb, and that Transgender people would have an intermediate imprinting. It is clear from Diamond’s survey though that evidence does not currently support this conclusion. The current evidence states that Sexed Behavior is imprinted in the womb, but that gender identity is co-mediated by biology, society, culture and psychology.
If we read Joanne’s hypothesis as relating to Sexed Behavior rather than gender identity, some transsexuals may have more strongly imprinted sexed behavior than transgender people. There is an alternative reading that transgendered and transsexed people share the same biological cross-sexed behavior, but differ in in socially mediated gender formation.
The point is, we do not know yet. No research has ever been done on the difference between No-ho trans, no-op trans, crossdresser and transsexual brains. There is no biological evidence to support a genetic basis for a transsexual, transgender, cross-dresser split. Until then, if transsexuality is seen as an intersex condition than so is gender-variance. Although from an organization-activation perspective cross-sexed is a better term than intersexed.

Advertisements
Comments
  1. Joanne says:

    Hello Jasper 🙂
    You wrote:

    Joanne seems to be hypothesizing that Gender identity is a result of Organization-activation in the womb, and that Transgender people would have an intermediate imprinting.

    No Jasper. I’m pointing out that there is not an either/or, one size fits all explanation for these things.

    Gender identity can only be acquired via the process of post natal gender role conditioning. It is perfectly clear that, although all humans receive some degree of gender role conditioning, not all of them are responsive to it and others respond to different degrees.

    Organization/activation provides an explanation for why that situation occurs. It is both fallacious and misleading to refer to an identity acquired by gender role conditioning on the one hand, and the somatic dissonance experienced by classical transsexuals, resulting from sex reversed organization – activation on the other, as both being .gender identity. issues.

    This model easily explains why David Reimer could not be convinced he was a female, and a significant number of other similar attempts have also failed. Despite that there are at least two examples of that same process being effective in other genetic males.

    I think the problem here is that John Money’s theories have lead too many people down the garden path for too long.

  2. Case says:

    RIP Jo. May your insight into the great debates help lead us through a labyrinth rather than any old maze of garden paths.

  3. Jasper Gregory says:

    What happened to Jo? Her blog is down

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s